Modular Home vs. Stick-Built: Which Has a Better Resale Value?
When buying a home, considering the resale value is crucial for homeowners and investors. The resale value is a significant factor as it determines the ability to recoup the initial investment and generate a profit when the home is sold.
Two common options in the housing market are modular homes and stick-built homes. Understanding the differences between these two types of construction is crucial in making an informed decision.
Modular homes have gained popularity in recent years due to their affordability, shorter construction timeframes, and customization options. These homes are constructed in a controlled factory environment away from the building site and later transported for final assembly on-site. On the other hand, a stick-built home, also known as a site-built home, is constructed entirely on-site.
In this article, we compare these two types of homes, focusing on their resale value and the factors that influence them.
What is a stick-built home?
A stick-built home, also known as a site-built home, is a type of home that is constructed on-site. It is the traditional method of constructing a home that comes to mind for most individuals when they contemplate building a house. The construction process involves assembling the home's framework from scratch, using materials such as lumber, nails, and screws.
The construction process for a stick-built home typically begins with excavating the foundation. After the foundation is set, the next step is the home’s framing. The framing consists of erecting the walls and roof of the home using wood studs and beams.
Once the framing is complete, the home is covered with sheathing, which is a material that provides a weather-tight barrier. The home's exterior is then finished with siding, and the interior is finished with drywall, flooring, and other materials.
The construction timeline for a stick-built home typically ranges from 6 to 12 months, including the time needed for banking and acquiring permits. Some factors that influence the timeline include labor, the availability of construction materials, customization and design, weather conditions, and the house size.
Stick-built homes offer a wide range of customization options, allowing homeowners to create a home that meets their specific needs and wants.
Some of the most common customization options include:
Floor plan: You can choose the layout of your home, including the number of bedrooms, bathrooms, and other rooms.
Exterior: You can choose the style of your home's exterior, including the type of siding, roofing, and windows.
Interior: This includes the finishes for your home's interior, including the type of flooring, cabinets, and countertops.
Amenities: You can include amenities in your home, such as a pool, spa, or home theater.
Understanding Modular Homes
Modular homes, on the other hand, are built off-site in a factory-controlled environment. The construction involves building the home in modules or sections, which are then transported to the building site for final assembly. Modular homes are not manufactured homes, which are built according to different and lower and less efficient specifications and different codes than modular homes.
The materials used in modular construction are the same as those used in stick-built homes, but the factory-regulated environment ensures higher quality and more efficient construction. The time frame for completing a modular home is generally shorter than that of a stick-built home, often ranging from four to five months.
Some factors could impact this timeline, including the house size, site preparation, and post-construction touch-ups during the installation of appliances.
Modular vs. Stick-Built Homes
Let's compare modular and stick-built homes side by side to better understand their differences in terms of cost, construction time, and design flexibility.
Cost: Modular homes are generally more cost-effective than stick-built homes. The factory-regulated environment allows for better cost control and reduced waste. Additionally, bulk purchasing of materials and efficient construction processes contribute to cost savings.
Construction Time: Modular homes can be completed in a shorter time than stick-built homes. Construction delays due to weather conditions are minimized since the modules are built concurrently with site preparation. On the other hand, stick-built homes are more susceptible to weather-related delays.
Design Flexibility: While stick-built homes offer virtually unlimited design options and customization, modular homes have come a long way in terms of design flexibility. There is a wide range of floor plans and architectural styles to choose from. Some modular home styles include Chalet, Two-story, Mansion, Ranch, Cape Cod, and Colonial.\
Modular homes have faced misconceptions and concerns regarding their resale value. Here are some common concerns about modular homes:
-
Modular homes are built to the same standards as stick-built homes, and in fact, many modular homes are built to even higher standards due to the controlled conditions under which they are constructed.
-
Modular homes can be customized to a great extent. You can choose from various floor plans, styles, and finishes and have the home built to your specifications.
-
Modular homes can be just as eco-friendly as stick-built homes. In fact, many modular homes are built with resource-saving features, such as insulation, double-paned windows, and energy-efficient appliances.
-
Modular homes are as safe as stick-built homes and are often built to meet or exceed all applicable building codes.
-
Modular homes are just as durable as stick-built homes. They are built with materials designed to withstand harsh elements and hundreds of miles of interstate travel during the delivery.
-
Modular homes can be just as easy to sell as stick-built homes. They appreciate at a rate that is similar to stick-built homes.
Reasons Why Modular Homes Are Just As Valuable as Stick-Built Homes
Modular homes are just as valuable as stick-built homes for several reasons, including:
They offer cost-effectiveness stemming from efficient production and reduced labor and material waste.
They can be customized to meet individual preferences and needs, providing a high level of personalization.
They are built with quality construction techniques and materials, ensuring durability and long-term value.
They are energy-efficient, offering potential savings on utility costs and attracting environmentally-conscious buyers.
These factors combine to make modular homes a valuable and competitive option in the housing market.
Do Modular Homes Hold Their Value?
Modular homes have been gaining popularity in the housing market due to their numerous advantages, including cost-effectiveness, shorter construction timeframes, and high-quality construction. However, a common question among potential homebuyers is whether modular homes appreciate in value over time.
One factor that contributes to the value and appreciation of modular homes is the quality of construction. Modular homes are built in a factory-supervised setting, where strict quality control measures are implemented. Precision machinery and skilled labor ensure a higher level of craftsmanship and attention to detail compared to on-site construction. This focus on quality can positively impact the long-term value of modular homes.
Another factor is the energy efficiency of modular homes. With advancements in construction techniques and materials, modular homes can be built with superior insulation and energy-efficient appliances. These features not only reduce utility costs but also increase the overall value of the property.
As environmentally-friendly construction becomes an increasingly important consideration for homebuyers, the demand for energy-efficient modular homes is expected to grow, leading to potential appreciation in value.
Modular homes offer significant advantages in cost, construction time, and quality. This cost-effectiveness can contribute to the home's initial value, providing homeowners an affordable investment option.
Additionally, the shorter construction timeframes associated with modular homes allow you to occupy your property sooner, potentially capturing market appreciation at an earlier stage. Moreover, the reduced timeframes minimize the expense you may incur for additional housing costs such as rent, mortgage payments, or hotel accommodations.
Concerns that modular homes depreciate are often unfounded. Some may assume that because modular homes are built in a factory, they may not hold their value as well as stick-built homes.
However, studies have shown that modular homes appreciate in value similarly to stick-built homes in comparable markets. Modular homes' quality construction, durability, and energy-conserving features contribute to their long-term value, making them a viable investment option.
Tips for Maximizing Resale Value
There are several steps you can take to maximize your modular home value:
Invest in Energy-Efficient Upgrades: Energy-saving features reduce utility costs and increase your home's appeal to potential buyers. Consider opting for eco-friendly windows, insulation, appliances, and lighting.
Regular Maintenance: Keep your home in good condition by performing regular maintenance tasks such as cleaning gutters, servicing HVAC systems, and addressing any necessary repairs promptly.
Thoughtful Landscaping: Enhance your home's curb appeal by investing in landscaping that complements the architectural style of your home. Well-maintained gardens, trees, and outdoor living spaces can significantly impact the resale value.
Select a Reputable Builder: A reputable builder is crucial. Ensure they have a track record of delivering high-quality construction and craftsmanship.
Timeless Designs: When choosing the design for your home, consider options that have broad appeal. Unique and timeless designs are more likely to attract a wide range of buyers compared to highly customized homes that may appeal to a narrower audience.
Conclusion
Modular homes offer several advantages that can contribute to their value and appreciation over time. The cost-effectiveness, shorter construction timeframes, and high-quality construction make them an attractive choice for homeowners. Factors such as the quality of construction, energy efficiency, and market demand for sustainable housing all contribute to the appreciation potential of modular homes.
Ultimately, the resale value of a home is influenced by various factors such as location, market conditions, and the overall quality of construction. Consider weighing your priorities and preferences before making a decision.
Research and learn as much as you can about modular and stick-built homes. Read online reviews, talk to friends and family who have experience with either type of home, and visit model homes. The greater your knowledge, the more informed your decision-making will be.